Aaron Tveit

Thomas 'Tommy' Reilly

Edy Ganem

Alejandra 'Allie' Batista

Lou Diamond Phillips

Monsignor Renzulli

Gregory Alan Williams

Judge Watford

Yohance Myles

Willis 'Silk' Thompkins

Spence Maughon

Vick Vargas

Lauren Helling

Jane

John Newberg

Kent Dunbar

David Joseph Martinez

Mario Batista

Lauren Compton

Nikki

Jo-Ann Robinson

Louisa Reilly

Ladson Deyne

Father John

Mikki Val

Betty

Susan LaBrecque

Dr. Sylvia Touran

Joshua Powell

Photographer

Camryn Jones

Samantha

Charles Adams

Protester / Courtroom Guest / Couple (uncredited)

Anthony Barbier

Courthouse Cop (uncredited)

Chad Governale

Detective (uncredited)

Victoria Hardway

Protester / Courtroom Guest / Couple (uncredited)

Cynthia LeBlanc

Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)

Elton LeBlanc

Doctor (uncredited)

Aaron Mitchell

Juror (uncredited)

Shaquita Smith

Nurse (uncredited)