Vincent Price

James Addison Reavis

Ellen Drew

Sofia de Peralta-Reavis

Vladimir Sokoloff

Pepito Alvarez

Beulah Bondi

Loma Morales

Reed Hadley

John Griff

Robert Barrat

Judge Adams

Margia Dean

Marquesa de Santella

Jonathan Hale

Governor

I. Stanford Jolley

Mr. Richardson

Tina Pine

Rita

Angelo Rossitto

Angie -- Gypsy

Edward Keane

Surveyor General Miller

Barbara Woodell

Mrs. Carrie Lansing

Fred Kohler Jr.

Demmings

Tris Coffin

McCleary

Gene Roth

Father Guardian

Abdullah Abbas

Indian (uncredited)

Walter Bacon

Townsman (uncredited)

Eumenio Blanco

Gypsy (uncredited)

Buck Bucko

Vigilante (uncredited)

Wheaton Chambers

Brother Gregory (uncredited)

Noble 'Kid' Chissell

Townsman (uncredited)

Richard Cramer

Townsman Watching Reavis Return to Arizona (uncredited)

Russell Custer

Townsman (uncredited)

Tex Driscoll

Townsman (uncredited)

Sam Flint

Board Member - Department of Interior (uncredited)

Terry Frost

Morelle - Vigilante (uncredited)

Rudy Germane

Officer (uncredited)

Pat Goldin

Diminutive Franciscan Monk (uncredited)

Herman Hack

Guard (uncredited)

Stuart Hall

Party Guest (uncredited)

Tex Holden

Townsman (uncredited)

Stuart Holmes

Man in the Governor's Mansion (uncredited)

Mathew McCue

Townsman (uncredited)

Forbes Murray

Board Member - Department of Interior (uncredited)

Lee Phelps

Guest at Governor's Mansion (uncredited)

Stanley Price

Mr. Reynolds (uncredited)

Buddy Roosevelt

Townsman (uncredited)

Jeffrey Sayre

Townsman (uncredited)

Bert Stevens

Man at Governor's Mansion (uncredited)

Jack Tornek

Townsman (uncredited)

Blackie Whiteford

Townsman (uncredited)