Loretta Young

Sister Margaret

Celeste Holm

Sister Scholastica

Hugh Marlowe

Robert Masen

Elsa Lanchester

Amelia Potts

Thomas Gomez

Luigi Rossi

Dorothy Patrick

Kitty

Basil Ruysdael

The Bishop

Dooley Wilson

Anthony James

Regis Toomey

Monsignor Talbot

Mike Mazurki

Sam

Walter Baldwin

Claude Jarman (uncredited)

John Bleifer

Rosey (uncredited)

Nan Boardman

Nun (uncredited)

Robert Foulk

New York City Policeman (uncredited)

Eula Guy

Mrs. O'Connor (uncredited)

Louis Jean Heydt

Al Newman (uncredited)

Nolan Leary

Bethlehem Station Master (uncredited)

Henri Letondal

Father Barraud (uncredited)

Ian MacDonald

Mr. Matthews (uncredited)

Marion Martin

Rossi's Manicurist (uncredited)

Edwin Max

Whitey (uncredited)

Frank Richards

Lefty (uncredited)