Elizabeth Montgomery

Lizzie Borden

Fionnula Flanagan

Bridget Sullivan

Ed Flanders

Hosea Knowlton

Katherine Helmond

Emma Borden

Don Porter

George Robinson

Fritz Weaver

Mr. Andrew Borden

Bonnie Bartlett

Sylvia Knowlton

Helen Craig

Mrs. Abby Borden

Hayden Rorke

Julien Ralph

Gloria Stuart

Store customer

John Beal

Dr. Bowen

Alan Hewitt

Mayor Coughlin

Gail Kobe

Alice Russell

Amzie Strickland

Adelaide Churchill

Robert Symonds

Andrew Jennings

Iggie Wolfington

Store Proprietor

John Zaremba

Judge Blaisdell

J. Edward McKinley

Marshall Hilliard

Norman Stuart

Dr. Wood

Jon Lormer

Bailiff

Lynn Wood

Mrs. Raymond

Olan Soule

Eli Bence

Judson Morgan

Justice Morgan

John Alvin

Dr. Draper

Patricia Wilson

Hannah Reagan

Tracie Savage

Young Lizzie

Joan Crosby

Companion

Jason Johnson

Jury Foreman