Lucille Ball

Christine Larson

James Craig

Jonathan Ware

Cedric Hardwicke

Lord Warrick (as Sir Cedric Hardwicke)

Dean Jagger

Jim Sawyer

Peter Whitney

Willie

Billy Gilbert

Homer Burnaby - Justice of the Peace

Tom Tyler

Geronimo

Antonio Moreno

Chief Cochise

George Cleveland

Bill Yard

Stanley Andrews

Major at Court Martial

Ed Brady

Soldier at Hitching Rail

Chester Clute

Wilber - Governor's Secretary

Iron Eyes Cody

Indian

Chester Conklin

Soldier at Hitching Rail

Fern Emmett

Spinster

Al Ferguson

Soldier at Hitching Rail

Lloyd Ingraham

Man on Street

Ethan Laidlaw

Johnson

Tom London

Trooper Parker

Francis McDonald

Governor's Interpreter

George Melford

Dr. Thomas

Bud Osborne

Private Tom Rose

Jay Silverheels

Indian

Al St. John

Bearded Man Hurrying to Wedding

Carleton Young

Nolte