As Good as It Gets
A comedy from the heart that goes for the throat. Brace yourself for Melvin.
Melvin Udall, a cranky, bigoted, obsessive-compulsive writer of romantic fiction, is rude to everyone he meets, including his gay neighbor, Simon. After Simon is hospitalized, Melvin finds his life turned upside down when he has to look after Simon's dog. In addition, Carol, the only waitress at the local diner who will tolerate him, must leave work to care for her sick son, making it impossible for Melvin to eat breakfast.
Wokeness: 0%
Overall Score: 100%
Please Log in to Submit a Review!
User Submitted Reviews
LmaoXD-kun
"I think of a man and I take away reason and accountability"
As Good as It Gets is a masterpiece of the "they’d-never-make-this-today" variety. It’s sharp, brutally honest, and lets its characters be flawed, complex humans instead of sanitized moral mascots. Jack Nicholson plays Melvin Udall who's an author with OCD who hates everyone equally. Women, gays, Jews, blacks, you name it—no one’s safe from his verbal grenades. And yet, Jack Nicholson plays him so well that you don’t just tolerate him; you want him to win. Helen Hunt plays Carol who's a struggling single mom with a no-nonsense charm, who gives him a reason to get his act together. She’s not there to fix Melvin like some Disney princess swooping in with a fairy-tale ending. Instead, she makes him work for her affection, and that's part of the appeal, and their chemistry is fire.
Highlights? Everything Melvin says. Period. You’ll laugh, you’ll cringe, and you’ll wonder how today's "safe space" culture would never greenlit this type of movie. Another highlight I would like to mention is the gay artist played by Greg Kinnear. Simon isn’t just there as a "token gay character" (a trap so many movies fall into); he’s a fully realized person with his own struggles, ambitions, and vulnerabilities. In a lesser movie, Simon would’ve been a one-note "gay best friend" caricature, but here, he’s a crucial part of the story. His storyline avoids modern preachiness. It’s there to support the story, not push an agenda. Whether you care about representation or not, Simon’s just a damn well-written character IMO.
Bottom Line: Melvin is a jerk, but a hilariously real one, and his redemption arc feels messy in all the right ways. The humor hits hard, the emotions run deep, and the performances are so good they’d make today’s safe, corporate Netflix rom-coms weep with envy. It’s bold, it’s honest, and it’s better than 90% of the stuff Hollywood churns out today. Watch it.
Created: 01-21-2025