Andrew Garfield

Jonathan Larson

Alexandra Shipp

Susan Wilson

Robin de Jesús

Michael

Michaela Jaé Rodriguez

Carolyn

Ben Levi Ross

Freddy

Vanessa Hudgens

Karessa Johnson

Joshua Henry

Roger Bart

Bradley Whitford

Stephen Sondheim

Judith Light

Rosa Stevens

Laura Benanti

Judy

Danielle Ferland

Kim

Micaela Diamond

Peggy

Utkarsh Ambudkar

Todd

Gizel Jiménez

Cristin

Kate Rockwell

Lauren

Joel Perez

Lincoln

Judy Kuhn

Nan

Richard Kind

Walter Bloom

Joanna Adler

Molly

Sheila Tapia

Nurse

Christopher Jackson

TTB Concert Attendee

Jelani Alladin

David

Chuck Cooper

"Sunday" Legend #1

André De Shields

"Sunday" Legend #2

Renée Elise Goldsberry

"Sunday" Legend #3

Joel Grey

"Sunday" Legend #4

Wilson Jermaine Heredia

"Sunday" Legend #5

Beth Malone

"Sunday" Legend #6

Howard McGillin

"Sunday" Legend #7

Brian Stokes Mitchell

"Sunday" Legend #8

Bebe Neuwirth

"Sunday" Legend #9

Adam Pascal

"Sunday" Legend #10

Bernadette Peters

"Sunday" Legend #11

Phylicia Rashād

"Sunday" Legend #12

Chita Rivera

"Sunday" Legend #13

Daphne Rubin-Vega

"Sunday" Legend #14

Phillipa Soo

"Sunday" Legend #15

Eisa Davis

Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Tom Kitt

Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Steven Levenson

Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Dave Malloy

Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Stephen Schwartz

Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Marc Shaiman

Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Derrick Delgado

Young Michael

Mason Versaw

Teenage Jon

Roger Bart

Featured Diner #2

Lane Napper

Bookstore Dancer #1

Lin-Manuel Miranda

Diner Manager (uncredited)

Stephen Sondheim

Stephen Sondheim (voice on phone) (uncredited)

Jonathan Larson

Self (archive footage) (uncredited)