Michelle Bernard

Judy (Chanukah)

Darren Lynn Bousman

Orignial Killer Santa (Christmas)

Alexandra Boylan

Josi (Thanksgiving)

Arielle Brachfeld

Girl in Woods (Halloween)

Micah Cohen

Party Goer (New Years)

Michael J. Epstein

Mr. Keane (St. Patrick's Day)

Josh Hammond

Jesse (4th of July)

Lisa Mason Lee

Diane (New Years)

Bobbi Sue Luther

Party Guest (Christmas)

Rene Michelle Aranda

Party Goer (New Years)

Victoria Matlock

Jessica / Party Game Player 1 (New Years / Father Time)

Maitlyn Pezzo

Holly (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Michael Varrati

Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)

Jeff Wiesen

Cop / James (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)

Wes Sneeringer

911 Operator (uncredited)

Lauren Chavez-Myers

Lilith Hicks (Easter)