Calvin Lee Reeder

Gary (segment "Tape 56")

Kentucker Audley

Rox (segment "Tape 56")

Adam Wingard

Brad (segment "Tape 56")

Simon Barrett

Steve (segment "Tape 56")

Andrew Droz Palermo

Fifth Thug (segment "Tape 56")

Joe Swanberg

Sam (segment "Second Honeymoon")

Sophia Takal

Stephanie (segment "Second Honeymoon")

Kate Lyn Sheil

The Stalker (segment "Second Honeymoon")

Hannah Fierman

Lily (segment "Amateur Night")

Nicholas Tecosky

Bartender (segment "Amateur Night")

Chad Villella

Chad (segment "10/31/98")

Matt Bettinelli-Olpin

Matt (segment "10/31/98")

Tyler Gillett

Tyler (segment "10/31/98")

John Walcutt

Cult Leader (segment "10/31/98")

Drew Moerlein

Joey Brenner (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Glenn McQuaid

Victim in River (segment "Tuesday the 17th")

Helen Rogers

Emily