Robert Redford

Jim Grant

Shia LaBeouf

Ben Shepard

Brendan Gleeson

Henry Osborne

Terrence Howard

FBI Agent Cornelius

Susan Sarandon

Sharon Solarz

Nick Nolte

Donal Fitzgerald

Chris Cooper

Daniel Sloan

Stanley Tucci

Ray Fuller

Julie Christie

Mimi Lurie

Richard Jenkins

Jed Lewis

Anna Kendrick

Diana

Brit Marling

Rebecca Osborne

Sam Elliott

Mac McLeod

Stephen Root

Billy Cusimano

Jackie Evancho

Isabel Grant

Keegan Connor Tracy

Jim Grant's secretary

Lochlyn Munro

FBI Agent Munro

Matthew Kimbrough

Barnes

Gabrielle Rose

Marianne Osborne

Lucie Guest

Bikini Girl

Susan Hogan

Florida Woman

Erin Simms

New York Hotel Clerk

Bethany Brown

Record Store Clerk

Kelly-Ruth Mercier

Gas Station Cashier

Gabriela Reynoso

Maria

Marsha Regis

Albany Times Assistant

Andrea Brooks

Sharon Solarz's Daughter

Dawn Chubai

News Anchorwoman #1

Sophie Lui

News Anchorwoman #2

Allison Riley

New York Newswoman

Donna Lysell

Eva Sloan

Nicole G. Leier

Gas Station Customer

Jennifer Bradley

Billy Cusimano's Daughter

David Milchard

Ann Arbor County Clerk

David James Lewis

Albany FBI Agent Lewis

Jon Johnson

Albany FBI Agent Johnson

Isaiah Adam

New York Cameraman

John Shaw

DMV Source

Bernie Yao

Car Rental Clerk

Bruce Dawson

Sharon Solarz's Husband

Jackson Warris

Sharon Solarz's Son

Dale Wolfe

Ann Arbor Reporter

Mark Brandon

New York Anchor #1

Jan Bos

New York Anchor #2

Clay St. Thomas

80's Reporter

Barry Bowman

80's Newsman

Fred Henderson

80's Anchorman

Dan Gerrity

70's News Anchor

Mark Pawson

On-Site Journalist

Peter Jenkins

Dad on Train

G. Michael Gray

Drunk on Train

Jessica Williams

Jess (uncredited)

Lexie Huber

Jim's Wife (uncredited)