Ray Milland

Vernon Simpson

Jean Peters

Deborah Greenleaf

Paul Douglas

Monk Lanigan

Ed Begley

Edgar Stone

Ted de Corsia

Jimmy Dolan

Ray Collins

Alfred Greenleaf

Jessie Royce Landis

Mrs. Greenleaf

Alan Hale Jr.

Schmidt

Kathleen Hughes

Sarah (uncredited)

Mae Marsh

Greenleaf's Maid (uncredited)

Debra Paget

Alice (uncredited)

Ray Teal

Mac (uncredited)

William Murphy

Tommy Isbell

Robert Adler

Reporter (uncredited)

Johnny Calkins

Boy Sitting Next to Debbie at Ballpark (uncredited)

Harry Carter

Baseball Fan in Stands (uncredited)

Bill Cartledge

Newsboy (uncredited)

Harry Cheshire

Team Doctor X-Raying King's Hand (uncredited)

Al Eben

Parker - Team Trainer (uncredited)

Gene Evans

Batter Mueller (uncredited)

Sandra Gould

Mabel on Telephone (voice) (uncredited)

Sam Hayes

New York Broadcaster (uncredited)

Edward Keane

Jack Bell (uncredited)

Kenner G. Kemp

Baseball Fan (uncredited)

Ruth Lee

Miss Collins - Prof. Greenleaf's Secretary (uncredited)

Lee MacGregor

Student (uncredited)

John McKee

Baseball Player (uncredited)

George Melford

Conductor (uncredited)

Debra Paget

Alice - College Co-ed (uncredited)

Robert Patten

Cab Driver (uncredited)

Grandon Rhodes

Professor (uncredited)

Harry Seymour

Jewelry Store Clerk (uncredited)

Mickey Simpson

Stadium Policeman (uncredited)

Douglas Spencer

Train Conductor (uncredited)

Bert Stevens

Man in Train Station (uncredited)

Brick Sullivan

Umpire (uncredited)

Max Wagner

Umpire (uncredited)

Robert B. Williams

Reporter (uncredited)