Paul Newman

Henry Gondorff

Robert Redford

Johnny Hooker

Robert Shaw

Doyle Lonnegan

Charles Durning

Lt. Wm. Snyder

Ray Walston

J.J. Singleton

Eileen Brennan

Billie

Harold Gould

Kid Twist

John Heffernan

Eddie Niles

Dana Elcar

F.B.I. Agent Polk

Jack Kehoe

Erie Kid

Dimitra Arliss

Loretta

Robert Earl Jones

Luther Coleman

James Sloyan

Mottola

Charles Dierkop

Floyd (Bodyguard)

Lee Paul

Bodyguard

Sally Kirkland

Crystal

Arch Johnson

Combs

Ed Bakey

Granger

Brad Sullivan

Cole

John Quade

Riley

Larry D. Mann

Train Conductor

Leonard Barr

Burlesque House Comedian

Paulene Myers

Alva Coleman

Joe Tornatore

Black Gloved Gunman

Jack Collins

Duke Boudreau

Ken Sansom

Western Union Executive

Ta-Tanisha

Louise Coleman

William Benedict

Roulette Dealer

Robert Brubaker

Bill Clayton from Pittsburgh (uncredited)

Kathleen Freeman

Kid Twist's Wife (uncredited)

Susan French

Landlady (uncredited)

Alexander Lockwood

Landlord (uncredited)

Byron Morrow

Mr. Jameson from Chicago (uncredited)

Arthur Tovey

Bank Officer (uncredited)